Peyton & Luke

With so many memories of Amelia Island, there was no better place Peyton Riley could think of to get married.

Every Amelia Island wedding begins with a beautiful backdrop, but the treasure of each special day comes from the couple’s own personal Island story. For Peyton Lawser, Amelia Island was more than simply the destination of her wedding day. It was home, filled with wonderful memories of family, friends, and growing up, and the only place she wanted to begin the next chapter of her life with Luke Riley.

Peyton and Luke first met while attending Appalachian State University in Boone, North Carolina. Luke was studying Construction Management, while Peyton was pursuing a degree in Elementary Education. Their friendship eventually grew into a lasting relationship, and by July 2024, Luke knew he wanted to spend forever with Peyton.

Under the guise of arranging to take some family photos along the beach at Emerald Isle, North Carolina, Luke gathered both families. But, instead of family photos, Luke got down on one knee, surrounded by all their loved ones and a photographer, and asked Peyton to marry him. Peyton said, “yes!” to Luke, and then “yes!” to planning her dream wedding on Amelia Island.

“An intimate, quiet marsh setting was super important for us, and it was special to find The Amelia River Club, a brand-new venue,” shares Peyton. “The first time we visited, it was all dirt. The team painted a vision for us, and Luke, being in the industry, agreed the floor plan was promising. I trusted them and said, ‘yes!’ one more time! I never actually saw the finished venue until the wedding day, and I was blown away.”

Having attended a wedding there just a week ago myself, I completely understand her reaction. The Amelia River Club’s newest event venue, The Preserve, opened in December 2024. “The Preserve is a permanent 10,000-square-foot Cape Cod-inspired waterfront venue designed to host large-scale events,” owners Tom and Michelle Miller explain. “Flooded with natural light and finished in a soft, neutral palette, the space was created to feel both elegant and adaptable. The Preserve includes expansive indoor-outdoor entertaining areas, bridal and groom suites, a commercial prep and catering kitchen, and accommodations for up to 450 guests.”

For Luke and Peyton, it offered everything they had envisioned – beautiful views, modern amenities, and a setting that felt distinctly Amelia Island. In July last year, the couple exchanged vows in an intimate marshfront ceremony beneath Amelia Island’s majestic live oaks, where Peyton’s brother officiated before a gathering of family and friends, including nieces serving as flower girls.

Like so many weddings on Amelia Island, the celebrations started well before the wedding day. Friends and family traveled from near and far to enjoy an Amelia Island wedding weekend. The couple hosted a brunch at Café Karibo, spent time on the beach with guests, and introduced visitors to some of their favorite local spots, including Tasty’s, where Peyton worked throughout high school and into college, Aloha Bagel, and the Green Turtle Tavern. Guests stayed around the island, including the Hampton Inn & Suites Amelia Island Historic Harbor Front Hotel in downtown Fernandina Beach, as well as private vacation rentals at various locations.

Today, the newlyweds look back fondly on a wedding weekend filled with meaningful moments, family traditions, and the natural beauty of the island they love. When they aren’t reminiscing about their celebration, they enjoy spending time with their Golden Retriever, Goose, planning their next visit to Amelia Island, and preparing to welcome their first baby into the world.
For Peyton, Amelia Island was more than a wedding destination, it was the chance to share the place she loves the most with family and friends, while creating memories that will last for a lifetime together.